GREEN BAY, Wis. — In the world of the NFL, the holiday season is traditionally a time for star quarterbacks to shower their offensive linemen with lavish gifts—ranging from Rolex watches to customized ATVs—as a thank-you for a season of protection. However, Green Bay Packers signal-caller Jordan Love is finding himself at the center of a social media firestorm after his 2025 holiday offerings were deemed “underwhelming” by the court of public opinion.
Love, who secured a massive four-year, $220 million contract extension last summer, reportedly gifted his offensive line a package consisting of customized “Love” branded winter beanies and pairs of UGG slippers. While the gesture was intended to be a cozy nod to the frigid Green Bay winters, fans and critics were quick to point out the stark contrast between Love’s $55 million-per-year salary and the estimated $150 retail value of the gift set.
The backlash began almost immediately after images of the gifts surfaced on Instagram and X (formerly Twitter). Critics labeled the 26-year-old quarterback a “cheapskate,” with many comparing his gift to those of his predecessors and peers. Historically, Aaron Rodgers and Brett Favre were known for more extravagant gestures, and across the league, other quarterbacks have gifted their lines luxury travel bags or high-end electronics this season.
“You sign for $220 million and give the guys who keep you from getting hit a hat and some slippers?” one viral post questioned. “That’s not a gift; that’s a stocking stuffer.”
Despite the online noise, members of the Packers’ offensive line have not publicly expressed any dissatisfaction. In fact, several younger players on the roster noted that the “Love” branded apparel has become a popular item in the locker room. Teammates often defend these gift choices as more personal than a generic luxury item, emphasizing the camaraderie within the unit.
However, the “Cheapskate” narrative has gained significant traction due to the high-profile nature of NFL contracts in the modern era. As the face of the franchise, Love’s every move—both on and off the field—is scrutinized through the lens of his record-breaking paycheck.
This isn’t the first time an NFL quarterback has been critiqued for “budget-friendly” gifts, but the timing for Love comes as the Packers navigate a high-pressure push for the playoffs. While the controversy is unlikely to affect the team’s chemistry on the field, it serves as a reminder of the unique expectations placed on the league’s highest-paid stars during the holiday season.
Love has yet to comment on the criticism, focusing instead on the Packers’ upcoming Week 17 matchup, where he will once again rely on the very linemen he gifted to keep him upright in the pocket.
